Ah, but there is a bit of subtle strategy in having simple non glossy leaflets. Its the "I am just a straightforward tradesman, poor but honest" approach and it does work. Also, I always include my full name, address and home number.
It has worked
Have you ever tried something different from that?
If you're marketing from a pity point of view, as "just the simple, make this flier at home window cleaner", that could be powerful, but you should really tap into that more, and create a little story, and build your brand around it.
How well has your way worked? Whats your response rate? And what are your prices like, in comparison to the other local guys?
Sorry for being a while coming back on this one. I didn't say I made the fliers myself although with a computer today anything is possible.
My prices are top end of the range of prices charged locally and I do get quotes turned down for being too high. I work in the ritcher suburbs of North West London and virtually all my customers live in houses worth $1 million plus, some are worth many times that.
My books are full and we are not really taking on any new work at the moment. We only do regular cleans, no one offs.
I find generally I get a fairly good response from leaflets, 90% of my business has been built from leaflets. but you can never predict, sometimes a leaflet will result in a call years after its been delivered. Thats why I favour an A5 leaflet they get kept.
The reason my leaflets stand out in my opinion is precisely because they are not like all the glossy rubbish, pizza menus, etc that drop through every door every day.
I really think you guys are missing the point, the world is full of bland but well thought though out and cleverly worded glossy leaflets that never get read because they look like all the other bland but clever glossy leaflets. You are designing them to go straight in the bin. How many people are going to stand and read that lot?
A simple but honest leaflet, no silly type faces etc with your full name and address, if it hits the right spot sends out a very strong message about YOU and your approach to business. Thats not going for the pity vote as you put it. Its saying "I'm a regular guy, you can trust me, its OK to have me working round your house, you can leave me the keys when your away"
Thats what people really want. Don't sell clean windows sell trust.