Doug
I would consider the SLWCN to be far more advanced than the guild, you have actually lobbied government and forced them into action, so you are to be commended on that.
The APWC and the Fed were both government recognised as they were both registered as bona-fide trade associations.
That is the key they both went down the route of relevent criteria to be registered as a government approved trade association.
Safe contractor is recognised by government in the fact that if you are registered with Safecontractor it pre- approves you for
www.chas.gov.uk, so no more forms to fill in, also it is backed by qualified H&S professionals.
The BWCA is recognised to an extent because it is also an NVQ centre and runs Iosh courses.
I must point out the fed also run an Iosh course, in fact they were instrumental in its content.
Until the Guild fulfill one or more of the above points then it is just a club.
Dave