Down here in Cornwall the need for winter gloves is more limited, which is probably why I hate wearing winter weight gloves - I find them restrictive.
I do however like wearing summer-weight work gloves and wear these all year to protect my hands. What I have started doing this year is slipping a pair of latex gloves on underneath my summer-weight gloves. I have about 3 pairs of work gloves and when the first pair get soaked I switch gloves, but keep the latex under-gloves on. I have found that this gives me a good balance of ease of use, with protection from the chill factor.
Perhaps if I lived 'up country' this would not be enough and I would need the extra warmth of winter gloves.