I've got a digital varistream & it was a nightmare to start with BUT this was down to the (also new) pump being faulty which was replaced (shurflo 100psi)
Now, after replacing pump & with plenty of fine-tuning the settings it works a treat! It's robust with no external parts hanging off to break. They do take some fine-tuning though so be patient for a couple of days. The pressure switch is now electronic so no replacing these again. I'm a one man set up & with the 100psi pump i only need to use flow rate on setting 1 (0 to 9). The pump is hardly turning at this, only ticking over so should prolong it's life.
Mine is a ready-made pump box (plug & play) from cleantech, great service- especially when pump was faulty, they sent me a new one the same day!

I've not used any other pump controller though.
Hope this helps.
Tony