O'Rings are generally made from Nitrile and sometimes Viton which is harder (they are also poisonous so don't chew one.) I think that if you look up Nitrile you will find that it is very chemical resistant and it wouldn't suprise me if the "chemical resistant" ones are nitrile anyway. Viton is a little more resistant and a little more expensive, but never pay more than 10p for an O-Ring unless it's the size of an armband.
I used to be a hydraulics engineer and for those of you in Leeds I would recommend Hydraulic Equipment Supermarkets, ask for Peter and he'll probably just give you the O-Ring for free anyway as the minimum order charge is a fiver.