I have asked a few times on here, is paying piece rate still legal, that is how my old man employed for years, the better the employee the better % they got, I myself work on piece rates in the late eighty's but I was also paid a very basic rate if we couldn't work for whatever reason.
I wouldn;t think paying a piece rate was illegal per se, but any target set would have to be able to accomodate comfortably the national minimum wage.
makes sense, it used to be pretty much standard in commercial to pay piece rate, I know my brother used to make very good money as I did when employed by larger firms on piece rates, but I was only a teenager. about three years ago I was asked to quote some work but I ran it past my dad and brother and they both asked who I was quoting for, I mentioned the name and they both laughed and said get in writing as he will promise the world and not pay, both my dad and brother had been employees and he stopped their wages because they were earning to much because they were on piece rates and were making more than him

the girl in the office phoned my brother on the thursday night and told him he wasn't getting paid and why, so my brother took the van on the friday and drove to work with the squad of guys to work then phoned him up and said why are wages not in the bank, he said I am not paying you that amount, so my brother said fine your van and crew are in dundee get them home yourself, I will get the train, none of the lads could drive

he eventually stumped up from petty cash, but for the life of me I couldn't see why he didn't realise that the more the employee made the more the company made.
the guy I am talking about was a director and still is for a west coast firm in scotland.
jings that was an outburst, but anyway I like the idea of piece rate or bonus but pay the lads well and it can only be good with the right lads