Interesting is that Rob. Where I live, the water tds is 70 - ish, which isn't much compared to some. However, it seems that the tds doesn't pose a problem with the filter but, the sediment density of the water!
I tried both types of Fibradine filters and had the same problem with both.
Gardiners were excellent in helping sorting the problem out by the way. No complaints there. The bottom line was, they are just not suitable for my water.