It is not only the lifting of the pile, the amount of grit and sand that you get out of the carpet is considerable and something that cannot be achieved by a rotary. If anything the flattening og the pile will inhibit the extraction of this crud.
Even people with truckmounts realise the importance of agitation as it will dissapate the prespray to all surfaces of the fibre.
I have had so many people say to me their machine is that powerful they do not need to agitate but once they have worked side by side with me to compare results they quickly become converted. There is a good reason for manufactures being able to sell their wares at the prices they do.
Kid yourself if you wish but the investment in a good machine for aggitation makes a big difference to the result.
Peter
www.carpetcleanercardiff.com