Clean It Up

UK Floor Cleaning Forum => Carpet Cleaning Forum => Topic started by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 01:32:57 pm

Title: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 01:32:57 pm
Hi all,
         Apart from making a bigger hole in my wallet what is something like M-Power at £65 per 5 ltrs going to give me performance wise compared to say prochem extraction-pro at say £8, I realise it may have been asked before but I,d like your input so I know cheers klinger ???
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: Phillip Mold on January 31, 2008, 01:52:04 pm
The short answer is try it, beg, buy or borrow a sample.   

I paid £20 for a 1 litre sample a year ago and now use it whenever I can. Customers love it, No residual chemicals and despite only being in this game for 15 months 30% of my business are now repeat or referral.

Just come back from a £165 job, used 15 lites of prespray which I think is heavy compared to other cleaners. This means 0.125 litres of M Power, using your £65 figure for 5 litres cost was £1.625. I do not know the cost of your other product but I do not regard M Power as expensive.
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: Joe H on January 31, 2008, 01:53:38 pm
5 litres of M-Power is going to give you 600 litres of prespray ie 120:1
Solutions UK work this out at 1p per sq yd (or metre-cant remember)

Whats the ratio of the Prochem?
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: markpowell on January 31, 2008, 02:07:00 pm
prochem extraction pro is a detergent that you mix in the solution tank as a rinse, if you were to use prochem multipro for a prespray you would need 20 x 5litre to make 600 litres if mixed at 1 part to 6 parts water. this would cost £180.
So yes i would say that M Power at £65 for the 600 litres it produces is very good value for money.
Mark
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 02:21:04 pm
Extraction pro has a dilution rate of 100:1 M-power 120:1 similar dilution rates, so it still makes it 7-8x more expensive ,and is it that much better if so what makes it better? :-\
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: markpowell on January 31, 2008, 02:32:47 pm
you are comparing a pre-spray to a detergent.
If you are happy using prochem products, why not try crystal green mixes 1-500 in solution tank as oppose to extraction pro at 100-1 works out loads cheaper.
If you use m power as a prespray you only need rinse out with fresh water, trust me i have tried all different ways and it does work out cheaper.
Mark
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 02:46:43 pm
Are suggesting that you can only pre-spray with micro splitters such as m-power then? I havent been going that long only here to learn a bit but I have had good results using extraction  pro just wondered if they,d be even better using m-power or such like
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: markpowell on January 31, 2008, 02:55:27 pm
What do you use as a traffic lane cleaner / pre-spray now?
Mark
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 03:20:33 pm
ultraprep or the extraction pro when soiling is light + agitation
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: stevegunn on January 31, 2008, 05:01:38 pm
Prochems pure clean or nemesis super are better options as they work out cheaper than m power,nemesis very similar to m power

Site sponsor sell 4kg pure clean £18.65
nemesis available from restormate £39.99 5 ltrs
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: markpowell on January 31, 2008, 05:23:52 pm
Pureclean from olympic cleaning for £13.65
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on January 31, 2008, 08:42:20 pm
Look it sounds like I,m being tight, not at all...I just really wondered if you clean an averagely soiled carpet properly with say m-power  and also properly with say extraction pro is there going to be much difference in the final result either time-wise or quality of the clean? Now if you know for sure we.re going to get a superior carpet clean its worth every penny and every one should use it...I,m waffling now, but come on is there that much difference? :P
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: Darren O on January 31, 2008, 09:14:36 pm
Extraction Pro is total crap i used to use it for about 2 years didnt no any better.Then i tried formula 90 must be one of the best detergents out there,double clean is good to but you are better with f90.
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: Phillip Mold on February 01, 2008, 12:20:24 am
Strange, none of you chemical users has mentioned the  high ph you will be leaving behind?

Unless you address the residue issue then the poor custy will end up thnking that the carpet DOES need cleaning again!

Reminds me of something:

 bodgett and SCarper profesuanal kleeners
 
Introducing a special offer for two weeks only. Half cleaned pricing in your area.
 
article written by Chris Myers (MBICSc) IICRC Thames Valley Carpet Care
 
 
 
Ok Ok, we've all seen the leaflets. In fact most of our customers seem to show us these flyers and invite our comments. Well, I came into this industry by answering an ad in my local labour exchange. I lasted about three weeks with the company and to this day I'm not sure whether I was sacked or resigned, the two coming within seconds of each other. Talking to Gerry Parks at Warwick about my experiences, he thought that they might make interesting reading, so here goes.
Glossary of terms used in the leaflets.
Fully trained technician = 2 days out with another tech, receiving useful advice such as "if it's not dirty don't clean it"
Latest high tech equipment = Italian made wet vac similar in power to Henry's big brother. No spotting chemicals, no prespray and one tub of very high pH powder.
Hundreds of satisfied customers =
thousands of really p****d off ones.
Prices from = we have to charge extra for stains, the type of carpet, prespray, stainguard, extra time taken etc etc etc. Bait & switch.
Curtains cleaned on site whilst hanging (this is the best one) = Mist the air near the curtains with white spirit then dry vacuum.
My brief career
I was based in an office in St Ives, Cambridgeshire, although most of the work I was given was for Southend, Basildon, Rayleigh etc. The deal was that I got £12.00 per day car allowance, 20% of the job price and 40% of any extras. With suites at £25.00 and 3 bed houses at £37.50 the pressure is on to upsell the ticket. Stainguarding was the easiest and I'm ashamed to say that I sold a lot of it. I'm ashamed because I believed what I was told "that a capful of stainguard in the solution tank is plenty". One 5 litre container of stainguard was expected to last us at least 2 weeks and if it was running low we were told to water it down. Times allowed were 2 hours for a 3 bed house and 1 hour for a suite, this included travel to the next job, which could easily be 1/> an hour away. My problem was that I went against the company guidelines and attempted to clean. This resulted in me always running
 
However, it had been noted that I didn't get any call backs, and in fact two customers had called the office and expressed their satisfaction with the job. This caused some consternation in the office as this situation was not covered in the operating manual. What to do with a cleaner that wasn't fast enough but never got call backs to reclean. Solution, promote him to assistant office manager and send him out on any recleans.
This was effectively the beginning of the end, already unhappy with the quality of my own work, I was truly aghast at what I was being confronted with on the recleans, and spending most of my day working with very irate customers was, to say the least, demoralising. On the last day I was working in Rayleigh, I was more or less on schedule as my previous customer (not a reclean) had booked to have a set of curtains cleaned, and since I flatly refused to clean curtains, I refused to do it. I utilised my usual technique of teeth sucking, then saying "well missus, in my experience, this particular kind of fabric doesn't respond well to our system" and suggested she cancel me. I always told the customer to tell the office that they had heard very bad complaints from somebody else, and strangely enough they always believed her. This was my fourth set of curtains and I didn't do any of them. On this occasion however they told her that she would have to pay a cancellation fee, to which she responded "well that's what your bloke told me to say" result? THE SACK.
Meanwhile, blissfully unaware of this I was working down the road on a reclean of a particularly badly soiled carpet. The customer had seemed even more offhand than usual, but on seeing the carpet that she had complained about I could see her point. I was therefore completely unprepared for what happened next. I was kneeling down working in a corner when I heard the front door open, the next thing I know is I'm on my back, already having been kicked in the ribs, with another kick being aimed at my face. Rolling out of the way and getting to my feet, I realised that I disagreeailant was about a foot shorter, several stone lighter and about ten years older than me, and I was just about to kick sevens bell out of him, when his wife rushed into the room saying "stop, that's not the bloke". It turned out that the first cleaner had been
 
new film, Confessions of a carpet cleaner, and had made several comments and innuendos, making the lady feel very uncomfortable indeed. The husband, naturally had taken exception to this and it was me that reaped the consequences. The outcome? My RESIGNATION. This was the last straw and, as you can imagine, the air was blue as I walked back into the office. It took several moments to realise that whilst I was quitting the boss was sacking me. I guess I'll never know who got in first.
The silver lining however was that I'd been introduced to an industry I hadn't even realised existed, I'd found a brochure from a company based in Acre Rd, Kingston and realised that there was a lot more to this game, and I was certain that I could do a better job than that rabble. The year was 1991, I bought my first machine, second hand, booked myself on the 2 day introduction to carpet cleaning and the rest, as they say, is history.
I worked fairly successfully by myself for the next seven years, undercharging, thinking of all other carpet cleaners as the enemy, generally believing that I was doing a fairly good job. That was until I went to Swindon, where I was introduced to the IICRC. This in turn introduced me to Paul Pearce and thus to the NCCA. I would just like to say that the help, information and advice that I have received since being involved with both has been immeasurable. I now enjoy a much better lifestyle and instead of thinking of this business as a means to an end, I am now proud to be a carpet cleaner, and look forward in the future to also putting something back in.D
NB Bodgett & Scarper is a fictitious trading name and reference to a cleaning company of that name is neither implied or intended, and lets face it, we know who they are.
Membership Details
Every day we receive calls from the general public requesting details of members in their area
Although these calls are being logged, we thought it
appropriate that we highlight this benefit to the members, particularly as we realised we are doing this
more and more frequently. During the last month the details of 291 members
have been given out.
The standard procedure for giving out member's
details fairly is to select 3 me..iber companies nearest
to the enquirer, it is then up to the enquirer to define
their appropriate choice.
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on February 01, 2008, 06:08:29 am
"But in a nut-shell"............... :P ;D
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: Darren O on February 01, 2008, 08:52:10 am
Detergents are fine to use on carpets as long as you stick to the dilution rates.I have been using detergents for 3 years and have loads of repeat customers and not had one complaint about resoiling also clean my own carpets and not had any resoilng problems with them either.Same old nonsense about detergents.
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: klinger (spa clean) on February 01, 2008, 09:07:37 am
It seems everyone in the CC trade is doing a good with no complaints and good referals....which leads us to think theres more than one way to skin a cat....(or clean a carpet) ;)
Title: Re: Performance comparison
Post by: markpowell on February 01, 2008, 09:08:57 am
I agree darren, i am a big fan of double clean and have never had the re-soiling problems that seems to be the opinion of some cleaners, i think some cleaners must walk into a customers house see highly soiled carpets and then double the amount of detergent they throw in the tank.
Mark