Clean It Up
UK Floor Cleaning Forum => Carpet Cleaning Forum => Topic started by: markas on September 16, 2004, 07:02:25 pm
-
Hi,
I am in the process of buying a new portable HWE machine, after looking at many options I have narrowed it down to 2 (Unless any new suggestions) either the Ninja or the more expensive Extracta exel as i've heard very good things of them.
Can anybody tell me any major problems either machine suffor from
Thanks in anticipation :)
-
Had 2 of them (exels), good machine, I put thousands of hours on them,excellent back up and supply service
-
Ive got a Ninja for about 2 years and just got the new alltec machine last week.
The Alltec has better water recovery due to the vacs setup and its easy to work on as the back comes off containing the vacs and pump. Better heater too as it goes to 90c. Looks more 'pretty' than the Ninja. Larger solution tanks, very quiet.
The Ninja is lighter and easier to manage. Its body work, being plastic, is more forgiving, its cheaper, more noisy than the alltec.
I'd buy the Alltec but you'll need a ramp into the van and a bit more TLC for the bodywork.
Mark
-
I've got the Excel and the Alltec Pro Plus. Much rather the Alltec machine. It looks good ( I know its not important ). Its lighter to carry. To me its easier to work on when changing vacs and pump. But you cant fault the service you get with Extracta. They are great people. Always helpful and Brian ( company founder and machine designer ) is always the man on the other end of the phone and a wealth of knowledge.
Chris
-
I agree with Extracta's back up service, they are second to none. They are the nicest people on the planet.
The only problem I had with the Excel is it was a bit on the noisy side, but it made me lots of money and I still use the scrubba machine on many jobs.
Phil
-
How would Prochems HSE top models compare to the machines mentioned? I run a commanche (now discontinued) and touch wood never been let down, parts and back up seem good too, when ordering some hose connections they arrived next day so only have good things to say but i'm sure some may disagree.
Paul
-
Markas
I am also looking to buy a new machine and am consdering the alltech and ninja among others. I would not be keen on the exel as it weighs 103lbs. Before you buy I would strongly advise you to at least try loading and unloading it into your car/van. Also try it on some stairs. It all depends on how the weight is distributed as to how hard it is. I tried this with a Cfr 400 which also weighs103 lbs and it was easier than the recoil which weighs 85lbs. The exel only has a 100psi pump though my catalogue is quite old this may have changed but 100psi is not much by modern standards.
On tuesday i went to A&M in watford to look at the cross american recoil. Robert there was very helpfull I got the feeling that they would be good people to do business with.
The recoil weighs 85lbs has 3 vacs and a 350psi pump
It is a fantastic bit of kit I can see why people more knowledgable than me like it so much. It is very noisy and quite awkward to load and get up stairs which put me off. Many people never take their machines upstairs it which case that is not such aproblem but for me it is about 20% of jobs.
The post from Mark_Roberts above should be read again and thought about as he has clearly just been through the same process. I know from reading his posts that he's knows the score, and will have made a good decission.
Mark_Roberts can I ask do you still have to use ramps even if you take the motors out. I was hoping that with the machine broken in two it would be easy for one man to lift in and out and take upstairs without help. Have you found out yet the size of the biggest pump you could fit and lastly what vac setup did you have on your ninja that has now been improved upon.
Regards Michel
-
hi Markas
if you get excell, tilt backwards on to rear wheels rest front wheels on to edge of van, lift and push, in she goes,even easyer if parked near curb, thats with expert type van, do not know about transit
Conrad
-
Using the method mentioned by Conrad, I can load the Recoil into the back of a Transit T300 with one hand.
This puts much less strain on the back than using a ramp.
-
Having used both Extracta and Alltec machines for many years now I have to say that Extracta are better built and sturdier machines than Alltec. In saying that Alltec are quite good machines but Extracta would be marginally better . However my next machine, when I purchase will be a Recoil.
-
Fintan, Is there an importer for the Recoils? I too would like a recoil when i upgrade next year having heard good things here on the forum.Anyone know if cross american will be at Carpex?
Paul
-
Paul
A&M in Watford are the UK distributors
Get down and have a look at one in the showroom, the team there are excellent ;)
-
dose any one know of a web address for reciol 3
thanks Davy
-
Thanks Woodman, I'll do that . So will i get to see one at Carpex??Any idea what the UK price for a recoil 3 is?
Paul
-
David,
http://www.cross-american.com
-
Paul,
Ed Valentine had hoped to be at Carpex, but other commitments prevent him attending with the Recoil.
Have a word with Robert McCane at A&M regarding price.
As Woodman has said, they are really great people to do business with.
John.
-
Thanks John. Do you have a recoil 3?
Paul
-
hi all,
Like Paul@ctcs, how much is the Recoil? Had info pack from A&M with spec' etc, but no prices enclosed!! ???
Regards
Martin S
-
machine about £2500 + vat , ive got the price list, will find it and post details later
Chris
-
Cheers Chris. ;)
Regards.
Martin S
-
i find the grace machine from craftex an excellent machine matching the pro plus machine from alltec which i have also and loads cheaper, only problem with it, it doesnt come with heater only an inline one which i havent tried to be fair....good luck!
-
The most up to date prices I have for the Recoil3 is£2495. The in line heater which Robert Mc Kane supplies is £415, the booster box is £549 and the optional tanks are£249 each. Plus vat of course.
-
Is the booster box a vacuum booster?
Paul
-
Ive got an Extracta model c it is over 20 years old and when it went in to Speedclean in Stoke for repair it sat next to a new Extracta model. They said they couldnt see the difference. Works and cleans like a dream
-
Paul, yes the booster box is a vaccum booster,an optional extra as the recoil3 also has a built in vac booster.
-
Markas
I've just constructed a ramp today which folds down from the back of the van really easy to use. My van is RWD so the floor is higher than normal otherwise is would be easy to tip the machine back and load onto the van.
Havent taken the back off yet as no need. Wouldnt be bothered taking the back off just to load into the van. Only for several flights of stairs. Its weight distribution is all at the back so its easier to take upstairs.
Havent checked the pumps yet but its tight in there so wont hold my breath.
Its vacs are in parralell (sp) so recovers more water than the Ninja = quicker dry times.
Mark
-
Mark Roberts..... I know you saw the Recoil3 in action, what made you decide to go for the Advantage , was it the weight factor .?
-
It was the heat issue and the noise of it that put me off although I really did want to get it as its a powerful portable. Few other wee niggely things as well but those could be put right as John Bolton did ie. no lid for fresh water tank etc.
Ed tells me hes now got a silencer on demo and someelse tells me it nows comes with a heater but too late for me.
Mark
-
Gentlemen;
I would like to respond to Marks Thread and comments. Which, btw, were very much appreciated with respect.
When our machines were designed some 28 years ago, the goal was that of a "Modular Design Concept". That meant to engineer all our systems so that the Operator could add other features to the exisiting unit without the purchase outlay for another machine. This in turn does two things:
1. Adds much greater Value. The Operator can get into a System for minimal expense; then build upon it as his own business grows.
2. Saves the Operator money since he does not have to purchase another machine as his business grow.
In conclusion; The RECOIL-3HP will accomidate many add-on modular components that will more than satisfy the Operator. Even Solution Lids!
I thank you for this opportunity to explain this uniqueness.
Good Fortune to All Brit's;
Ed Valentine
cross-american corp.
-
IMO a solution lid should be standard.
Mark
-
Hi Mark
How are you getting on with your Advantage, now you have had it for a while?
Mark
-
Mark (R),
I long ago decided that heating a tank of water outside the building, on a winters' day, 50, 75, 100 feet or more from where I was working, made little sense when the heat could be provided much closer to the wand. Therefore not having to pay for something I did not want or need was a bonus.
Much of the noise of the machine is due to the volume of air that is exhausted - clearly a machine that produces less airflow will be quieter. The pump also contributes to the overall volume, but would I be as happy with a nice quiet Flowjet 100psi?
Whilst I agree that a solution tank lid is a requirement, I was happy to design one that functioned the way I wanted, and let's face it everything added to a product increases the final price.
I find that I am using the Recoil far more than I expected since its' performance exceeded my expectations of it. All machines are designed and built around compromises, so whilst there are elements of the design I am not happy with, I can understand the compromises that brought them about and cannot say that the design and engineering decisions were wrong.
In the final analysis what I require is a machine that performs its' intended function as efficiently as possible within the parameters of size, weight and portability - this the Recoil certainly does.
John.
-
Have a look at the Raptor 230h from Hydramaster, 2 x 3 stage vacs, 300psi pump, 2 x 1000 watt in line heaters, great machine, about £2,500 + vat.
Alan
-
I hope this isnt seen as a recoil bashing exercise as I only stated what my opinion and decision was based on. Yes its a powerful machine but in its current format was not the machine for me. If this changes to my likeing then I'll buy it in two years when I next need a portable.
Hopefully all manufacturers reading this and all posts on their products will take note and build us machines tools that WE the cleaners want and not what they think we want. Any businessman worth his salt will take and use criticism either way.
Mark Betts
I like the advantage a lot more than the Ninja now that Ive used if for a few weeks. Very quite, easy to move, all the switches and vac/solution connects are at the top so no bending over so much, easy cleaned recovery tank, dryer carpets etc. Could do with more pressure though.
How do you like yours?
Mark
-
Ed
I went to look at the recoil last week at watford and like Mark Roberts above I was put off by the noise. Any chance of a add on modular component such as a silencer! As regards heat, John Bolton in his recoil diary say that it worked just fine with his high pressure steamate.
Re the advantage does anybody know the max size pump that could be fitted to this machine as the standard one it comes with is135psi. I did try calling alltech to ask but could,nt get much sense out of them.
Regards Michel
-
Indeed, Michael, you wo'nt get much satisfaction from them, but then Robert will teach you how you should keep in touch with your customers, wish they could do the same for theirs.
-
Michel,
I've had only three customers comment on the noise of the Recoil.
In each case I have grinned broadly and said "Yes, very powerful, I could switch of one or two of the motors to make it quieter !" The response was as predicted.
The problem with silencers is that unless the are very large (much larger than the machine they are silencing) they have a detrimental effect on the airflow through the machine. in some cases the performance hit may be a worthwhile sacrifice, but on most occasions the performance will be the paramount consideration.
-
John, I agree that a noisy machine gives the impression of a Powerful machine that has the ability to get customers carpets really clean, and how often do you guys actually get complaints??
I worked ten years in Engineering, now that is a noisy environment, some of those machines literally would leave you deaf in a few hours if you didnt wear ear protection, so maybe this is why i dont see a problem?.....Or maybe i'm half deaf already??
Paul
-
I dont care what the customers think of the noise as they only have to put up with it for a few hours. I'm more concerned with my earing over a period of time. I've found even the CFR tool with make my ears ring after 2.5 hours of use.
Mark
-
Mark, If you are concerned about your hearing you should look into getting some quality ear deffenders, I worked for ten years in engineering, 5 as an apprentice and 5 in production design engineering, a bulk of this time i worked in close proximity with seriously noisy machines and tried numerous types of ear deffenders. The Best by far are made by Peltor, they will eliminate the noise from an extraction machine no problems and unlike many you can wear for hours in comfort. They even do a pair with a totally built in FM/AM radio which would help keep bordom at bay on big commercial jobs.
All this and you wont go deaf ;D
Paul
-
Mark,
Did you not see my post regarding CFR Combi Tool whistle?
Observe where the trigger valve enters the tube - That air-gap is what causes the whistle. I have constructed a plastic gasket to solve the problem but silicone sealant would also work - just make sure that it is fully set before use.
John.
-
Thanks John. I'll try that.
I do use ear protectors but then I cant hear the phone although the radio ones sound interesting.
Mark