dave f

you learn somthing new every day
« on: June 28, 2017, 06:49:31 am »
while I am off the road I  was doing a bit of reserch on  diesel vans what a shock I got, any vans  with a dpf need at least 15miles motorway driving to get it warmed up thus any short distance stop start driving is no good has it  starts to get clogged over a period of time only way round it is to remove it which will result in mot failure. I have known people having the d p f gutted and welded back up

p1w1

  • Posts: 3873
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #1 on: June 28, 2017, 07:52:25 am »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

Dry Clean

  • Posts: 8540
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #2 on: June 28, 2017, 08:21:13 am »
Most vehicles have a warning light and its just a matter of a quick run down the motorway when it comes on.

Tony dunmall

Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #3 on: June 28, 2017, 09:23:21 am »
I was really surprised my daughter bought her first car recently a Toyota Yaris 1.4d and it started having problems dpf its 14 years old never knew they were around back then

All my vans have them and you need to get it hot enough to burn of the muck if you live near a bypass or motorway your fortunate enough

They've told me 15-20 mins 3rd gear 3000 revs minimum

Which is eealy hard in the new connect as that me breaking the speed limit real pain

EandM

  • Posts: 2167
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #4 on: June 28, 2017, 09:43:40 am »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

You usually blank off the EGR which is a little different.
You can physically remove a DPF which then needs to be mapped out of the ECU and all will be well.
Starting 2018 though the MOT is supposed to be including a DPF check  which can determine if it's working or not...or indeed present.

Spruce

  • Posts: 8366
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #5 on: June 28, 2017, 10:16:30 am »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

You usually blank off the EGR which is a little different.
You can physically remove a DPF which then needs to be mapped out of the ECU and all will be well.
Starting 2018 though the MOT is supposed to be including a DPF check  which can determine if it's working or not...or indeed present.

The DFP filter on a diesel is 'tested' by a visual inspection to see if it there.  It just like the catylatic convertor on a diesel. They just check to see if its there. - its not tested to see if its working or not, unlike a petrol vehicle.

Here's a little info regarding how a dpf filter effects the smoke test that the mot inspector does on diesels.

https://www.avontuning.co.uk/blog/dpf-removal-new-mot-regulations-will-it-pass-or-fail

however Vosa fights back;
http://garagewire.co.uk/news/mot-changes-to-be-introduced-in-may-following-dpf-investigation/
.
Success is 1% inspiration, 98% perspiration and 2% attention to detail!

The older I get, the better I was ;)

tlwcs

  • Posts: 2061
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #6 on: June 28, 2017, 03:50:13 pm »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

What's his van?

EandM

  • Posts: 2167
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #7 on: June 28, 2017, 05:01:30 pm »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

You usually blank off the EGR which is a little different.
You can physically remove a DPF which then needs to be mapped out of the ECU and all will be well.
Starting 2018 though the MOT is supposed to be including a DPF check  which can determine if it's working or not...or indeed present.

The DFP filter on a diesel is 'tested' by a visual inspection to see if it there.  It just like the catylatic convertor on a diesel. They just check to see if its there. - its not tested to see if its working or not, unlike a petrol vehicle.

Here's a little info regarding how a dpf filter effects the smoke test that the mot inspector does on diesels.

https://www.avontuning.co.uk/blog/dpf-removal-new-mot-regulations-will-it-pass-or-fail

however Vosa fights back;
http://garagewire.co.uk/news/mot-changes-to-be-introduced-in-may-following-dpf-investigation/
.

The VOSA info is interesting.  Yes the visual test has been there for a long time but as said it only proves that the DPF might be present but not necessarily working. The proposals were to actually measure the particulate emissions as they should be with the DPF fitted. Removal on my 2.2 406 and remapping (including mapping out the now extracted DPF) would lift bhp from 136 to around 200 and eliminate a number of limp home emissions based issues. They're great when they work, less so when they don't.

Lee GLS

  • Posts: 3843
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #8 on: June 28, 2017, 06:04:54 pm »
If you get a 1.6 dispatch, expert, berlingo partner etc I'm pretty sure they do not have a dpf from what I have read

EandM

  • Posts: 2167
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #9 on: June 28, 2017, 06:43:05 pm »
If you get a 1.6 dispatch, expert, berlingo partner etc I'm pretty sure they do not have a dpf from what I have read

Peugeot were the first manufacturer to introduce them. 406 hdi had them in 1999 but only on selected models. Both of our 51 plate 2.0 hdi 110 don't have them but my 53 2.2 coupe does. They seem to be standard on the 1.6 hdi (dreadful engine!) but maybe not on the Light Commercials ?

andyM

  • Posts: 6100
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #10 on: June 28, 2017, 06:53:57 pm »
If you get a 1.6 dispatch, expert, berlingo partner etc I'm pretty sure they do not have a dpf from what I have read

My 1.6 Partner has a DPF.
One of the Plebs

craigR

  • Posts: 130
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #11 on: June 28, 2017, 07:03:32 pm »
Yep just in the process of having dpf sorted on citreon relay and it aint cheap.
They clog up up if just pottering around town. Need some high rev milage every few days ive been told. The daft thing is it needs to be reved higher than i would consider normal as even on a motorway i'd usually stay well below 3000 revs so its just going to happen. Apparently every few days when warm it needs over reving and filter blows out/ self cleans ?

dd

  • Posts: 2527
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #12 on: June 28, 2017, 07:15:48 pm »
If you have to rev engine high for a sustained period regularly to regenerate dpf then surely it achieves the opposite of what it is supposed to in reducing polluting emissions.

More sensible government legislation I suppose.

EandM

  • Posts: 2167
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #13 on: June 28, 2017, 08:51:44 pm »
If you have to rev engine high for a sustained period regularly to regenerate dpf then surely it achieves the opposite of what it is supposed to in reducing polluting emissions.

More sensible government legislation I suppose.

The idea being that it takes the particulates of oxides of nitrogen away from the close confines of the City and vaporises them over large, open spaces in the Country. If used within their design then they are very effective. If you're only going to potter around a town doing short, slow journeys then buy something small and petrol.

Don Kee

  • Posts: 4854
Re: you learn somthing new every day New
« Reply #14 on: June 28, 2017, 08:58:34 pm »
I was really surprised my daughter bought her first car recently a Toyota Yaris 1.4d and it started having problems dpf its 14 years old never knew they were around back then

All my vans have them and you need to get it hot enough to burn of the muck if you live near a bypass or motorway your fortunate enough

They've told me 15-20 mins 3rd gear 3000 revs minimum

Which is eealy hard in the new connect as that me breaking the speed limit real pain


Whoever told you 3000revs wants a slap, stick to 2000revs mate; even suggests between 1500-2500 in the manual

Not sure on other manufacturers but on ford vans its quite easy to know if they're regenerating
The exhaust starts sounding louders, revs slightly higher in idle and believe it or not the windscreen starts getting warm

When you think its regenerating (if you can) just stick it in third and drive an extra 10-15mins; doesn't need to be everytime mind, it's not always doable
Once a little puff of blsck comes out of the exhaust, job jobbed (harder to see if you have the short/half exhaust)

On a side note, a few people I know have found that filling the oil to the 'max' seems to cause theres to regen more often. Mines in for its service on monday, will find out why that might be (although I seem to find the dealers aren't massively clued up if the diagnostic machine hasn't got the answer...

Spruce

  • Posts: 8366
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #15 on: June 28, 2017, 10:01:45 pm »
If you get a 1.6 dispatch, expert, berlingo partner etc I'm pretty sure they do not have a dpf from what I have read

Peugeot were the first manufacturer to introduce them. 406 hdi had them in 1999 but only on selected models. Both of our 51 plate 2.0 hdi 110 don't have them but my 53 2.2 coupe does. They seem to be standard on the 1.6 hdi (dreadful engine!) but maybe not on the Light Commercials ?

The 2.2 was a dirtier engine than the 2.0hdi, that's why they fitted them with dpf filters. They were also 'developing' dpf technology back then.
Quite why Citroen chose the 2.2 and 2.0hdi in the Citroen C5 was beyond me. The 2.2 was rated at 136hp whereas the 2.0hdi at 110hp. But the 110 made a better tow vehicle. Then Ford put the 2.0hdi variant in the Jaguar in those days with 135hp.  I'm confused with the French logic.

Then to cap it all they put the 2.0 hdi in the smaller Relay vans and derated them to 84hp. They then used the 2.2 in the larger Relay vans but derated them to 104 hp. They then fitted the 110hp to the Citroen Dispatch which is smaller than the SWB Relay.  ???

Meanwhile the 1.9TDi that VW were using was the same engine base from 90hp to 150hp.
Success is 1% inspiration, 98% perspiration and 2% attention to detail!

The older I get, the better I was ;)

p1w1

  • Posts: 3873
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #16 on: June 28, 2017, 10:25:46 pm »
My mate blanked his off year's ago and it's never failed an mot.

What's his van?
Renault Kangoo..but EandM was right in saying it was his EGR that he blanked off after i asked him today( my mate).

EandM

  • Posts: 2167
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #17 on: June 28, 2017, 10:35:35 pm »
If you get a 1.6 dispatch, expert, berlingo partner etc I'm pretty sure they do not have a dpf from what I have read

Peugeot were the first manufacturer to introduce them. 406 hdi had them in 1999 but only on selected models. Both of our 51 plate 2.0 hdi 110 don't have them but my 53 2.2 coupe does. They seem to be standard on the 1.6 hdi (dreadful engine!) but maybe not on the Light Commercials ?

The 2.2 was a dirtier engine than the 2.0hdi, that's why they fitted them with dpf filters. They were also 'developing' dpf technology back then.
Quite why Citroen chose the 2.2 and 2.0hdi in the Citroen C5 was beyond me. The 2.2 was rated at 136hp whereas the 2.0hdi at 110hp. But the 110 made a better tow vehicle. Then Ford put the 2.0hdi variant in the Jaguar in those days with 135hp.  I'm confused with the French logic.

Then to cap it all they put the 2.0 hdi in the smaller Relay vans and derated them to 84hp. They then used the 2.2 in the larger Relay vans but derated them to 104 hp. They then fitted the 110hp to the Citroen Dispatch which is smaller than the SWB Relay.  ???

Meanwhile the 1.9TDi that VW were using was the same engine base from 90hp to 150hp.

It was either the 607 or the 406 coupe hdi that first gained a DPF.
I often drive my 2.2  and the parents 2.0 hdi back to back and the difference is remarkable. The 2.0 is a lot more reliable. All of ours have managed up to 250,000 miles without issue. The 2.2 has another 26 bhp but another 60 lb ft of torque which makes a huge difference to performance. It has tall gearing and is fairly slow to get to 20 mph but once it's moving it's very quick. I doubt my 2.8i Capri would beat it unless on a Motorway or track.
De-rating engines for commercial use is quite normal but why VW went the other way is baffling :)

p1w1

  • Posts: 3873
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #18 on: June 28, 2017, 10:41:30 pm »
Slightly off topic a bit but while there is some experts posting here wouldn't mind there opinion.
I have a 12 reg C max that has been running fine for a year, however last week it started  juddering a bit and the engine warning light came on.
Now the AA came out and did a diagnostic check which came up with an injector 4 problem as follows... We have recovered your vehicle.Patrol found the following fault code/s:System : Engine control 1 - 9FA / Diesel CR/EDC SID 807P126400 - Injector cylinder 4. Error Message : Malfunction.P013513 - Oxygen sensor heating. Error Message : Short to ground.U041800 - CAN communication with ABS/ESP control units. Error Message : Signal faulty.

After taking it to my local garage who i used for years and trust checked it all out and confirmed there was an issue with the injector and needed replacing while sorting the problem he came across an issue where at some point the lambda sensor (oxygen sensor) has been disconnected completely from the main wiring loom and the ecu has been re programed to ignore it.

After fixing the injector the car now sounds really bad when idling and  revving up to about 1500-1600 rpm (a bad knocking sound, he said in the old days they called it a diesel knock) after this its not so bad the car runs fine as such and gets slightly better as it gets warm. there is no loss in power while driving it but it just  sounds rough
Ive been advised that really only ford can now really look into it further as it needs the sensor re connected and the ecu but back to its factory settings ( problem is they have cut the wire somewhere along the wiring loom that connect to the oxygen sensor block) so I'm thinking and he can get his head round why would someone do this? the car does not bring up any fault codes now even though it has the problems mentioned. Could this have been done to try and bypass any dpf filter issues?
Does anyone have an idea on what could be going on? just dont understand why this would be done on a newish car with not that big of milage
The car has done 51k
any input would be great before i book it into fords.
just to add the car has been on 2 different diagnostics machines and neither have brought up any more fault codes after sorting the injector out, and the car as fine before the breakdown could there have been any other damaged caused over time with the sensor disconnected. My garage and the garage that did the injector are completely baffled.

Spruce

  • Posts: 8366
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #19 on: June 29, 2017, 07:50:08 am »
Slightly off topic a bit but while there is some experts posting here wouldn't mind there opinion.
I have a 12 reg C max that has been running fine for a year, however last week it started  juddering a bit and the engine warning light came on.
Now the AA came out and did a diagnostic check which came up with an injector 4 problem as follows... We have recovered your vehicle.Patrol found the following fault code/s:System : Engine control 1 - 9FA / Diesel CR/EDC SID 807P126400 - Injector cylinder 4. Error Message : Malfunction.P013513 - Oxygen sensor heating. Error Message : Short to ground.U041800 - CAN communication with ABS/ESP control units. Error Message : Signal faulty.

After taking it to my local garage who i used for years and trust checked it all out and confirmed there was an issue with the injector and needed replacing while sorting the problem he came across an issue where at some point the lambda sensor (oxygen sensor) has been disconnected completely from the main wiring loom and the ecu has been re programed to ignore it.

After fixing the injector the car now sounds really bad when idling and  revving up to about 1500-1600 rpm (a bad knocking sound, he said in the old days they called it a diesel knock) after this its not so bad the car runs fine as such and gets slightly better as it gets warm. there is no loss in power while driving it but it just  sounds rough
Ive been advised that really only ford can now really look into it further as it needs the sensor re connected and the ecu but back to its factory settings ( problem is they have cut the wire somewhere along the wiring loom that connect to the oxygen sensor block) so I'm thinking and he can get his head round why would someone do this? the car does not bring up any fault codes now even though it has the problems mentioned. Could this have been done to try and bypass any dpf filter issues?
Does anyone have an idea on what could be going on? just dont understand why this would be done on a newish car with not that big of milage
The car has done 51k
any input would be great before i book it into fords.
just to add the car has been on 2 different diagnostics machines and neither have brought up any more fault codes after sorting the injector out, and the car as fine before the breakdown could there have been any other damaged caused over time with the sensor disconnected. My garage and the garage that did the injector are completely baffled.

I would take the car to Ford and get them to put it on their diagnostic machine to identify the fault and sort the lambda sensor out.  Depending on their mechanic skills they may want to just replace the engine wiring harness, but they should be encouraged to find the source of the cut wire and reconnect it.   You may be able to find a Ford specialist garage near you with a good reputation. (We have a Citroen/Peugeot specialist near us and they are quality. Our local Evans Halshaw  Citroen workshop is one to stay away from).

Ford will also reprogram the ecu with their current standard program.

The reasons why someone has reprogrammed the lambda sensor out of the ecu is purely conjecture. One of the main reasons to remove the sensor and reprogram the ecu is to de-cat the exhaust.  At one time removing the cat was an easy way to gain more power. You maybe able to find contact details of the vehicles previous owner on your logbook and ask him if he can shed any light on it. I doubt he would admit to knowing anything even if he did.)

The lambda sensor measures the amount of oxygen in the exhaust gas and adjusts the amount of fuel accordingly.  So this could well be the reason why the engine is running rough.  Its either running too lean or too rich. Could this cause injector failure? Possibly.

I believe that that replacement injector also needs to be calibrated in.

There a lot of unscrupulous  diesel engine tuners out there that don't know what they are doing. They don't know anything about manipulating the ECU program code. So they buy a program  to order from a third party ('hackers' that could be based anywhere in the world) and all they do is flash that new program into the ECU.  (I can order a program for my Citroen Xsara 90 hp engine to bring it up to roughly 110hp without any vehicle modifications. Its called a Stage 1 remap. I buy it and they email it to me. As long as I have a laptop with the correct cables and program I can do it at home. I have no clue what I'm getting, I just have to accept that I getting what they say I'm getting.)

Not all local garages are equipped to fully diagnose ecu faults.  In my old motor trader days with Citroen OBD diagnostics was a hot potato. Legislation was telling the motor industry that OBD ports were to be "often to the public," (competition legislation, ie. Britsh Gas, Royal Mail etc.)  where the manufacturers wanted them "sealed" so only their diagnostic computers could identify faults.   The other issue was that manufacturers are responsible for vehicle emissions for the vehicles they sell so need to be tamper proof. (EU legislation wanted their cake and eat it to.)
So manufacturers came out with a 2 tier ecu program. Most cheap over the counter fault code readers could diagnose the basic level of faults such as MAP sensor issues etc. but couldn't read 2 level diagnostics. I think this is still much the same these days.

My gut feel is that the lambda sensor hasn't been programmed out because it was faulty, but rather because of engine tuning.  What you might find is that the cat needs replacing. (MOT inspectors do a visual check to see if its there but don't do an emissions check. So the trick is to cut the pipe, remove the cat contents and weld the pipe back on. So it looks like it has a cat on visual inspection. Up till a couple of years ago a catalytic convertor wasn't part of the MOT test and guys just used to replace the cat with a 'straight through' exhaust pipe. Now it is and MOT inspectors need to see its there. )

You might also find that the dpf filter has also had its guts removed. So this could be an expensive repair in the worst case scenario. Sorry!

That ESP fault also needs investigation as its linked to the ABS braking system.

My experience was that the AA were really good trouble shooters. When recovering a car to our workshops we found that their diagnostic skills were right 90% of the time. In fact often the mechanic assigned to the car would ask the AA what the problem was and what was needed to fix it.


Success is 1% inspiration, 98% perspiration and 2% attention to detail!

The older I get, the better I was ;)

p1w1

  • Posts: 3873
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #20 on: June 29, 2017, 08:50:04 am »
Thanks Spruce, that kind of what my local garage has been saying but cant understand why someone would cut it from the main wiring loom when you can simply disconnect the sensor by pulling it out of the plug it goes into. Also it was running perfectly fine before the injector problem but now runs very harsh after it has been replaced and programed to the car.
A trip to fords it is then  :'(.... best start cleaning when its raining too now  ;D

Thanks again...

Spruce

  • Posts: 8366
Re: you learn somthing new every day
« Reply #21 on: June 29, 2017, 10:37:25 am »
Thanks Spruce, that kind of what my local garage has been saying but cant understand why someone would cut it from the main wiring loom when you can simply disconnect the sensor by pulling it out of the plug it goes into. Also it was running perfectly fine before the injector problem but now runs very harsh after it has been replaced and programed to the car.
A trip to fords it is then  :'(.... best start cleaning when its raining too now  ;D

Thanks again...

If you have a look yourself you might be able to find that wire. It might be in a section of the harness near the sensor that looks like its been tampered with. Maybe they tucked it back into the wiring harness just to get it out of the way. It would be around a hot exhaust so hopefully they did the honourable thing.

What bugs me tbh is why they would remove the wire in the first place if they were going to program the sensor out of the ecu anyway.

The only way is is for Ford to flash the ecu with the correct program for the car and then do a diagnostics check to see what the problems are.

.
Success is 1% inspiration, 98% perspiration and 2% attention to detail!

The older I get, the better I was ;)